Critics Cite ‘Inconsistent’ Atlanta Murder Verdict

An Atlanta jury’s decision to acquit attorney Claud “Tex” McIver of malice murder but convict him of felony murder has put Atlanta’s legal defense bar on edge, studies  Facebook and Twitter and in television appearances, legal defense lawyers, civil litigators and former prosecutors decried the verdict as “inconsistent,” “repugnant” or simply just “crap.” The jury convicted McIver of murder for shooting and killing his spouse, Diane. Veteran defense attorney Webpage Pate posted a poll on his Twitter feed inquiring individuals if they agreed with a verdict he stated was “clearly a compromise by a divided jury” the place McIver “gets [a] everyday living [sentence] in any case.”

Pate stated about 60 % stated they disagreed with the verdict. He additional that it was “probably” weighted towards defense lawyers like him. The jury didn’t just convict McIver of felony murder previous 7 days. It also convicted him of aggravated assault, possession of a firearm throughout the fee of a felony and influencing the sole witness to the shooting in an in the long run unsuccessful effort to form her story to law enforcement. The jury turned down two prospects to discover McIver responsible of involuntary manslaughter as an alternate to malice murder or felony murder in reaching its verdict. An involuntary manslaughter conviction would have intended McIver engaged in reckless conduct that resulted in his wife’s loss of life but that he did not intend to get rid of her. Jurors obviously struggled with the challenge of regardless of whether the fatal shooting was intentional. The Tex McIver verdict astounds me,” defense attorney Ashleigh Merchant posted on her Facebook webpage. “How just could he not intend to get rid of her but as a substitute intend to shoot her?” Attorney Tom West stated the jury most likely did not know that malice murder and felony murder both of those have a everyday living sentence. “Jurors will need to know the effects of their steps, in particular the place, as in this article, the sentence is mandated by the Legislature,” he stated.

Shares 0

Post Author: gupta

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *